Deleting a TerdutServer removed the credential Secrets but never touched the
database, so a recreated one found a server that was already bootstrapped and
no key for it: /api/bootstrap answered 403 and the operator stopped at
BootstrapStateLost, whose message and DESIGN.md both said "delete and
recreate". That is how the terdut-demo install on the cluster got stuck on
2026-10-03: Helm's cleanupOnFail deleted its TerdutServer after a failed
upgrade, the recreate found the bootstrapped database, and it sat at Ready:
False for five days until the database was reset by hand. Recreating cannot
fix it, because the finalizer clears Secrets and the database is not its to
reset, so "a fresh create starts clean" was only ever true when the database
went with it.
spec.credentials.deletionPolicy is Retain by default: the finalizer keeps the
instance credential Secret (Delete removes it, as before). The bootstrap
checkpoint is always removed. Before calling /api/bootstrap, reconcile now
looks for the retained Secret and asks the server for the operator's own
service account with its token. Accepted: adopt it and skip bootstrap.
Rejected with 401/403: the Secret outlived a database reset, so ignore it and
bootstrap like a first install, which replaces it. Any other error retries.
terdut-server's own tests already call that endpoint with an instance-scoped
key, so the permission is not new.
BootstrapStateLost is still the answer when the server is bootstrapped and no
credential it accepts survives, but its message now names the Secret to
restore and says that recreating does not clear the database. DESIGN.md §6
says the same, and the chart passes the setting through as
terdutServer.credentials.deletionPolicy.
A retained Secret of a TerdutServer that is gone for good is an orphan to
delete by hand. It is inert: nothing adopts it unless the server accepts the
token.
Checked on the kind demo with a locally built image against the real
terdut-server v0.43.0: deleting the TerdutServer kept the Secret, recreating it
reached Ready with the same credential (identical hash) and both TerdutTeams
came back Ready with their original ids. The controller specs cover adoption,
a rejected token after a reset, the bootstrapped-and-rejected failure, and
both deletion policies.
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Niklas Ye
62664c93ff